Selling an Occupied BuildingA guide by Shaya Lowenstein, Lyon Stahl Investment Real Estate Call (323) 944-2221

For owners selling occupied buildings in Los Angeles

Tenant estoppel certificates when you sell an apartment building

A tenant estoppel certificate is a signed statement in which a tenant confirms the rent, the deposit and the terms of the tenancy, so a buyer can check your rent roll against it. A residential tenant generally has to sign one only if the lease requires it, so plan for some units to come back unsigned.

On this page
  1. What an estoppel certificate is
  2. What the certificate should confirm
  3. Does a residential tenant have to sign one?
  4. What to do when a tenant will not sign
  5. Timing, and getting the facts right
  • An estoppel certificate is the tenant's signed confirmation of the facts of one tenancy, which a buyer and its lender use to test your rent roll.
  • A residential tenant generally has to sign one only if the lease requires it.
  • Send a form filled in from your records. A certificate that asks a tenant to confirm something wrong starts a dispute in the middle of escrow.
  • Before the forms go out, agree with the buyer on what counts when a tenant does not sign.

What an estoppel certificate is

An estoppel certificate is a short document in which a tenant states the facts of the tenancy as of the day they sign it. The name comes from the legal idea of estoppel. A person who signs a statement that someone else relies on may be held to it later, so the certificate turns the tenant's version of the tenancy into something a buyer can rely on.

Your rent roll is your own account of the building. A buyer has no way to test it against the people living there except by asking them, and the certificate is how that question gets asked in writing. A lender financing the purchase may ask for certificates as well, because the rents are what repay its loan.

An apartment certificate does not need to be long. The tenant is confirming a handful of facts, and a one-page form in plain language is easier to read, easier to check and easier to return.

What the certificate should confirm

You or your agent prepare the form, so you decide what it asks. For an apartment unit, these are the items a buyer will want and the record you should check each one against before it goes out.

ItemWhy the buyer caresCheck it against
Names of the tenants on the leaseWho the buyer is renting toThe lease and any addenda
Start date, and end date or month-to-month statusHow long the current terms runThe lease
Monthly rent, and the date rent is paid throughThe income the buyer is paying forYour rent ledger
Security deposit heldThe credit the buyer receives in escrow and the refund it will owe laterYour deposit records
Prepaid rent, concessions or rent creditsMoney or discounts the buyer inheritsThe ledger and any written agreements
Parking, storage, pets and other extrasWhat the rent includesThe lease and addenda
Side agreements, promised repairs, or disputes with youObligations that are not in the fileYour correspondence and any complaints
Any buyout agreementWhether the unit may soon be vacant, and whether the tenant can still cancelYour filings with LAHD under LAMC section 151.31

For RSO units there is one more record to reconcile. LAHD requires owners to report each unit's rent and tenancy information every year through its rent registry, and registration is not complete until that information is in. Make sure the registry filing, your ledger and the certificate tell the same story before a buyer compares them.

Does a residential tenant have to sign one?

It depends on the lease. Where a written lease requires the tenant to sign an estoppel certificate, refusing can be a breach of the lease. Where the lease has no such clause, a tenant can generally decline. Read every lease in the building for the clause before you promise a buyer anything, because leases signed years apart in the same building may say different things.

Some lease forms go further. They set a short deadline for returning the certificate and say that a tenant who does not respond is treated as agreeing with what it says. That language may satisfy a buyer, but how far it reaches against a particular tenant who never signed is a legal question.

What to do when a tenant will not sign

Start by asking why. A refusal can come from a form that states something the tenant believes is wrong, or from not knowing what the document is. Both have simple fixes, so work through these in order:

  1. Correct the form if the tenant is right. A certificate that repeats an error in your records does more harm than a missing one.
  2. Explain what the document is and offer to go through it with the tenant, in their language if that helps.
  3. Invite the tenant to write in corrections, or their own statement of the facts, and then sign. A marked-up certificate still tells the buyer what the tenant says.
  4. If the tenant still will not sign, give the buyer the lease, the rent ledger, the deposit records and bank records of rent received for that unit.
  5. If the contract allows it, sign a certificate yourself for that unit stating the same facts. Your statement then becomes a representation you answer for, so check every line.

None of these fallbacks works unless the purchase contract says it does. When you negotiate the contract, decide what happens if certificates are missing. You can agree that a seller certificate stands in for a tenant's, that certificates from a set share of the units are enough, or that a missing certificate does not let the buyer cancel. Settling that before the forms go out keeps one tenant from holding up the whole closing.

Timing, and getting the facts right

A certificate speaks as of the day it is signed. Send the forms during escrow, once the buyer's timeline is set, so the rent and paid-through dates are still current when the buyer and lender read them. If a lease sets a deadline for returning the certificate, give the tenant at least that long.

Fill in the facts yourself from your records and ask the tenant to confirm or correct them. A blank form invites guesses, and a guess that differs from your rent roll becomes a question the buyer asks you to answer.

The deposit line needs the most care. Under AB 12, a deposit demanded or collected on or after July 1, 2024 is capped at one month's rent, apart from a narrow exception for small owners. The cap does not reach deposits collected before that date, so a long tenancy may properly show a larger deposit than a new one. The certificate should show the amount you actually hold, because that is the amount the buyer will be credited and will later have to account for.

Keep a copy of every certificate you send and every one that comes back. If the buyer or its lender later asks why a unit's rent or deposit differs from what a tenant signed, those copies are your answer.

Questions owners ask

What is a tenant estoppel certificate in an apartment building sale?

It is a short statement, signed by the tenant, confirming facts about one tenancy such as the rent, the deposit, the lease dates and any agreements with the landlord. The buyer and its lender rely on it to confirm the seller's rent roll.

Can a tenant refuse to sign an estoppel certificate in California?

A tenant whose lease has no estoppel clause can generally decline. Where the lease requires one, refusing can be a breach of the lease, but talk to an attorney before you treat a refusal that way, because pressure on a tenant can create its own liability in Los Angeles.

What if the lease says the tenant must sign within a few days?

Then the clause sets the duty and the deadline. Some lease forms also say that a tenant who does not return the certificate is treated as agreeing with it. How far that language reaches against a particular tenant is a question for your attorney.

Can escrow close without an estoppel from every tenant?

Yes, if your purchase contract allows it. The contract can accept a certificate signed by you for the missing units, the lease and payment records, or certificates from a set share of the units instead of all of them.

When should estoppel certificates go out?

During escrow, once the buyer's timeline is set. A certificate speaks as of the day it is signed, so one collected months before closing may be out of date by the time a lender reads it.

Confidential

Talk to Shaya about selling with tenants in place

Tell Shaya about the building and the tenancies. He will reply by phone or email to talk through timing, showings and what a buyer will ask to see.

Rather talk now? Call or text (323) 944-2221Or email shaya@lyonstahl.com
Property inquirysellapartmentbuildingwithtenants.com

Shaya Lowenstein

About Shaya Lowenstein

Multifamily Real Estate Advisor · Lyon Stahl Investment Real Estate · CA DRE #01942326

Shaya Lowenstein has worked in real estate since 2011, across brokerage, operations and development. His practice is apartment buildings and land in Southern California: repositioning and value-add work, land use and zoning analysis, and long-range planning for owners, investors and developers.

Shaya is a licensed real estate agent. He is not an attorney or a tax advisor, and nothing on this site is legal or tax advice. When a decision turns on the law or on your taxes, talk to a California attorney or a CPA.

830 S Pacific Coast Hwy, Suite D-200, El Segundo, CA 90245(323) 944-2221shaya@lyonstahl.com